Why did so many Red Dwarf viewers prefer Rimmer to Lister, when you're meant to think Lister is the cool one?
ChatGPT said:
The preference for Rimmer over Lister among some Red Dwarf fans likely stems from several factors that make Rimmer a more compelling or relatable character for certain viewers, despite Lister being framed as the "cool" one in the show. Here’s why:
1. Rimmer’s Complex Personality
Flawed and Relatable: Rimmer's many flaws—his insecurities, ambition, and overcompensation—make him a deeply human character, even when played for comedic effect. People often empathize with his struggles to succeed despite his obvious shortcomings.
Consistent Comedy Source: His pompousness, bitterness, and capacity for self-sabotage create some of the series’ funniest moments. Viewers who enjoy schadenfreude or dark humor might find him irresistibly entertaining.
Underdog Appeal: Despite being insufferable, Rimmer is often a pathetic figure trying (and failing) to be better. His lack of success makes him oddly endearing.
2. Lister’s "Coolness" Feels Subversive
Unconventional Cool: Lister’s portrayal as the “cool one” isn’t traditional. He’s lazy, scruffy, and doesn’t exhibit many aspirational qualities. While these traits are likable and make him unique, they might not resonate as strongly with viewers looking for a classic protagonist to root for.
Predictable Role: Compared to Rimmer, who is full of contradictions, Lister’s role as the laid-back everyman is less dynamic. Some fans might find his consistent slacker persona less engaging over time.
Post too long. Click here to view the full text.